Ubuntu Lucid Lynx- Separate home partition by default.

The next release of  the ever popular Ubuntu Linux, code named Lucid Lynx, is set to be in April 2010. This release is going to be an LTS and thus with it we hope to see even more stability and greater features than the current Karmic Koala.
There is however, one feature that I really want the developers to give careful consideration to during the development process of the Lucid Lynx. In all the Ubuntu releases that have come out, the default installation has the home folder on the same drive as the system files. This makes the task of upgrading to a new release or doing a reinstall very cumbersome.
What I think would be in the best interest of Ubuntu and for that matter its users is for the standard installation to have a separate partition for the home folder. So if one chooses to go with the default installation as most people do, the home folder should automatically be created on a separate partition on the hard drive with the system files on another.
Doing this will help safeguard the data of users, especially newbies should something go wrong such that they have no option than to wipe their hard drives clean. I also think it will help people learn more about their systems as they know their data is not directly at risk.
The issue of always having to backup one’s system can sometimes be a real pain especially where you have a very large amount of data. I think this simple but generally overlooked feature should really be given serious thought during the upcoming Ubuntu Development Summit for Lucid Lynx.

5 Replies to “Ubuntu Lucid Lynx- Separate home partition by default.”

  1. I'm against this. The problem is balancing free space across multiple file systems. If any runs out, it's a pain. Usually it's no trouble to copy a home directory, and maybe it will remind people to make backups. 😉

  2. Hi David
    I agree with you that people got to do back ups regularly, but really I think this ought to be given some consideration.

    I am wondering how difficult it would be to include a simple app like gparted in the default installation (I know it's always on the LiveCD but is never installed upon installation) and make it real intuitive so that people can resize when the need arises.

    How difficult do you think that would be my friend?

  3. http://operation420.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=45&t=1107&p=4111#p4111

    @david True, I end up filling up my partitions where my OS is stored anyways…

    On my laptop I used to have 2 partitions. EXT3 and NTFS for Ubuntu and Vista. I had problems reading the EXT3 from Vista (the inode size was to big or something) even with EXT2IFS and EXD2FSD. I wanted to have the same contents in my Music, Pictures, Documents, and Video folders on both OSes. Now I have 3 partitions. The same two I had before and a "Files" partition.

    Before that I went even further and had a separate hard drive for data. But with a Laptop you only have one (I seen one laptop with 2 hard drives) so that's out of the option.

    A disadvantage of this is I find my files partition full and end up storing files in the Windows installation and EXT partitions anyways…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.